Book Score

The AI Shelf · UK · Week 46, 2026

Cosy crime novels

The books ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini recommended over the last 4 weeks when asked for cosy crime novels: 288 answers to 12 questions worded the way readers ask.

Ranked by the share of sampled answers that recommend each book. Arrows flag changes for review; they do not establish a lasting trend. A dash means no change was flagged.

  1. 1–

    The Thursday Murder Club

    Richard Osman

    ChatGPT 51Claude 48Gemini 36for 11 of 12 questions

  2. 2–

    Agatha Raisin and the Quiche of Death

    M. C. Beaton

    ChatGPT 20Claude 6Gemini 33for 9 of 12 questions

  3. 3–

    The Murder at the Vicarage

    Agatha Christie

    ChatGPT 17Claude 22Gemini 14for 6 of 12 questions

  4. 3–

    A Murder Is Announced

    Agatha Christie

    ChatGPT 19Claude 14Gemini 20for 6 of 12 questions

  5. 5–

    Miss Marple: The Complete Short Stories

    Agatha Christie

    ChatGPT 3Claude 41Gemini 7for 7 of 12 questions

  6. 6–

    The Agatha Raisin MysteriesSeries

    M.C. Beaton

    ChatGPT 7Claude 22Gemini 13for 10 of 12 questions

  7. 7–

    The Magpie Murders

    Anthony Horowitz

    ChatGPT 13Claude 12Gemini 11for 6 of 12 questions

  8. 8–

    Still Life

    Louise Penny

    ChatGPT 1Claude 16Gemini 17for 8 of 12 questions

  9. 9–

    Lord Peter Wimsey

    Dorothy L. Sayers

    ChatGPT 2Claude 24Gemini 6for 6 of 12 questions

  10. 10–

    Inspector GamacheSeries

    Louise Penny

    Claude 31for 6 of 12 questions

  11. 11–

    Gaudy Night

    Dorothy L. Sayers

    ChatGPT 7Claude 12Gemini 11for 4 of 12 questions

  12. 12–

    The Marlow Murder Club

    Robert Thorogood

    ChatGPT 12Claude 8Gemini 5for 7 of 12 questions

  13. 13–

    Dublin Murder SquadSeries

    Tana French

    Claude 23for 6 of 12 questions

  14. 13–

    The Body in the Library

    Agatha Christie

    ChatGPT 5Claude 13Gemini 5for 6 of 12 questions

  15. 15–

    The No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency

    Alexander McCall Smith

    ChatGPT 5Claude 2Gemini 15for 6 of 12 questions

  16. 15–

    Chocolate Chip Cookie Murder

    Joanne Fluke

    Claude 1Gemini 21for 5 of 12 questions

  17. 17–

    The Pie & Mash Detective Agency

    J. D. Brinkworth

    ChatGPT 13Claude 8for 4 of 12 questions

  18. 18–

    This Is Not a Game

    Kelly Mullen

    ChatGPT 17Claude 3for 5 of 12 questions

  19. 18–

    Shrink Solves Murder

    Philippa Perry

    ChatGPT 13Claude 7for 4 of 12 questions

  20. 20–

    The Appeal

    Janice Hallett

    ChatGPT 17Gemini 1for 8 of 12 questions

  21. 20–

    The Sweetness at the Bottom of the Pie

    Alan Bradley

    Claude 9Gemini 9for 6 of 12 questions

  22. 20–

    Vera Wong's Unsolicited Advice for Murderers

    Jesse Q. Sutanto

    ChatGPT 9Claude 1Gemini 8for 5 of 12 questions

  23. 20–

    The Windsor Knot

    S.J. Bennett

    ChatGPT 4Claude 7Gemini 7for 4 of 12 questions

  24. 20–

    Albert CampionSeries

    Marjorie Allingham

    Claude 14Gemini 4for 3 of 12 questions

  25. 25–

    Meg LangslowSeries

    Donna Andrews

    Claude 17for 6 of 12 questions

Get this chart every Monday

What ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini recommend in cosy crime novels, and the sites they quote, in one short email. Stop any time.

Is your book on the AI shelf?

Paste its Amazon link. The free check asks the assistants what readers ask about books like yours, and shows what to fix.

Free. Email to open full results. About a minute.

The sites the assistants read for this list

Cited by ChatGPT and Claude while they answered. Sites marked Publisher list only their own books; the rest are lists, reviewers and press a book can be pitched to.

  1. penguin.co.ukPublisherin 19 answers
  2. goodreads.comCataloguein 7 answers
  3. penguinrandomhouse.comPublisherin 6 answers
  4. en.wikipedia.orgReferencein 4 answers
  5. theguardian.comPressin 4 answers
  6. mcbeaton.comWebsitein 4 answers
  7. agathachristie.comAuthor sitein 4 answers
  8. fivebooks.comBook listsin 4 answers
  9. hachette.co.ukPublisherin 3 answers
  10. crimereads.comPressin 3 answers
  11. deadgoodbooks.co.ukBook listsin 2 answers
  12. lovereading.co.ukBook listsin 2 answers
How this list is made

Every week we ask the same 12 questions, 2 times each, of ChatGPT and Claude (both searching the web live) and Gemini (answering from what it knows; Google's terms don't let tools like ours analyse its web-search answers). The questions are worded the way readers really ask. We read which books each answer recommends, count each book once however it is spelled, leave out any book or author the question itself named, and rank by the share of answers that name it. A list is published only when every assistant answered.

Selected rolling period: 288 answers (192 live, 96 from memory). Question set uk-2, run 9 November 2026.

  1. “What are the best cosy crime novels ever written? I want something proper comforting with a good puzzle.”
  2. “I've never really read cosy crime before, where should I start? Any easy first books to dip into?”
  3. “What are the best new cosy crime books that have come out in the last year or so? Fancy something fresh.”
  4. “Are there any underrated or lesser-known cosy crime novels worth reading? I've done all the big names already.”
  5. “Need a birthday present for my nan who loves a nice cup of tea and a cosy mystery, what cosy crime book would you get her?”
  6. “Looking for a cosy crime book to read on a rainy weekend with a blanket and a brew, any suggestions?”
  7. “Can you recommend cosy crime set in a village bakery or tea shop? Bonus if there's a bit of humour.”
  8. “I absolutely loved The Thursday Murder Club, what other books are like it?”
  9. “I've read everything by Agatha Christie and loved it, who should I read next?”
  10. “Which cosy crime novel would be a good pick for our book club that will get everyone talking? We're a mixed group of friends in our 40s and 50s.”
  11. “What are the best cosy crime novels by British authors? Proper English village vibes please.”
  12. “Is there a cosy crime series that's worth starting? I like getting stuck into a long series with characters I can get attached to.”

A list shows what the assistants said in the selected period through their APIs. It is not a ranking of quality or sales, and nobody pays to be on it. Repeated questions and shared models limit the independence of these answers. Read the method and limitations.