Book Score

The AI Shelf · UK · Week 47, 2026

Historical romance novels

The books ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini recommended over the last 4 weeks when asked for historical romance novels: 288 answers to 12 questions worded the way readers ask.

Ranked by the share of sampled answers that recommend each book. Arrows flag changes for review; they do not establish a lasting trend. A dash means no change was flagged.

  1. 1–

    Outlander

    Diana Gabaldon

    ChatGPT 19Claude 26Gemini 17for 7 of 12 questions

  2. 2–

    The Duke and I

    Julia Quinn

    ChatGPT 11Claude 9Gemini 28for 8 of 12 questions

  3. 3–

    Pride and Prejudice

    Jane Austen

    ChatGPT 10Claude 19Gemini 12for 5 of 12 questions

  4. 4–

    The Grand Sophy

    Georgette Heyer

    ChatGPT 13Claude 9Gemini 18for 4 of 12 questions

  5. 5–

    Lord of Scoundrels

    Loretta Chase

    ChatGPT 4Claude 3Gemini 28for 8 of 12 questions

  6. 6–

    Devil in Winter

    Lisa Kleypas

    ChatGPT 10Claude 9Gemini 15for 6 of 12 questions

  7. 7–

    The BridgertonSeries

    Julia Quinn

    ChatGPT 5Claude 22Gemini 1for 8 of 12 questions

  8. 8–

    The Bronze Horseman

    Paullina Simons

    ChatGPT 6Claude 19Gemini 1for 3 of 12 questions

  9. 9–

    The Nightingale

    Kristin Hannah

    ChatGPT 1Claude 23for 5 of 12 questions

  10. 9–

    All the Light We Cannot See

    Anthony Doerr

    Claude 24for 4 of 12 questions

  11. 11–

    Venetia

    Georgette Heyer

    ChatGPT 6Claude 4Gemini 13for 4 of 12 questions

  12. 11–

    Secrets of a Summer Night

    Lisa Kleypas

    ChatGPT 1Gemini 22for 4 of 12 questions

  13. 13–

    Flowers from the Storm

    Laura Kinsale

    ChatGPT 6Claude 4Gemini 11for 6 of 12 questions

  14. 14–

    A Lady's Guide to Fortune-Hunting

    Sophie Irwin

    ChatGPT 16for 8 of 12 questions

  15. 14–

    The Viscount Who Loved Me

    Julia Quinn

    ChatGPT 4Claude 2Gemini 10for 6 of 12 questions

  16. 14–

    A Week to Be Wicked

    Tessa Dare

    ChatGPT 2Gemini 14for 5 of 12 questions

  17. 14–

    These Old Shades

    Georgette Heyer

    ChatGPT 2Claude 8Gemini 6for 3 of 12 questions

  18. 18–

    Frederica

    Georgette Heyer

    ChatGPT 4Gemini 11for 2 of 12 questions

  19. 19–

    Cotillion

    Georgette Heyer

    Claude 2Gemini 12for 2 of 12 questions

  20. 20–

    Slightly Dangerous

    Mary Balogh

    ChatGPT 1Claude 2Gemini 10for 5 of 12 questions

  21. 20–

    A Kingdom of Dreams

    Judith McNaught

    ChatGPT 1Gemini 12for 5 of 12 questions

  22. 20–

    Persuasion

    Jane Austen

    ChatGPT 1Claude 4Gemini 8for 2 of 12 questions

  23. 23–

    The Pillars of the Earth

    Ken Follett

    Claude 10Gemini 1for 3 of 12 questions

  24. 24–

    The Duchess Deal

    Tessa Dare

    ChatGPT 4Claude 5Gemini 1for 4 of 12 questions

  25. 24–

    Romancing Mister Bridgerton

    Julia Quinn

    ChatGPT 3Gemini 7for 4 of 12 questions

Get this chart every Monday

What ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini recommend in historical romance novels, and the sites they quote, in one short email. Stop any time.

Is your book on the AI shelf?

Paste its Amazon link. The free check asks the assistants what readers ask about books like yours, and shows what to fix.

Free. Email to open full results. About a minute.

The sites the assistants read for this list

Cited by ChatGPT and Claude while they answered. Sites marked Publisher list only their own books; the rest are lists, reviewers and press a book can be pitched to.

  1. penguinrandomhouse.comPublisherin 11 answers
  2. en.wikipedia.orgReferencein 7 answers
  3. goodreads.comCataloguein 6 answers
  4. penguin.co.ukPublisherin 5 answers
  5. bookriot.comBook listsin 5 answers
  6. us.macmillan.comPublisherin 4 answers
  7. hachette.co.ukPublisherin 3 answers
  8. bookshop.orgShopin 3 answers
  9. underthecoversbookblog.comReviewerin 3 answers
  10. kirkusreviews.comReviewerin 2 answers
  11. randomolive.comWebsitein 2 answers
  12. publishersweekly.comPressin 2 answers
How this list is made

Every week we ask the same 12 questions, 2 times each, of ChatGPT and Claude (both searching the web live) and Gemini (answering from what it knows; Google's terms don't let tools like ours analyse its web-search answers). The questions are worded the way readers really ask. We read which books each answer recommends, count each book once however it is spelled, leave out any book or author the question itself named, and rank by the share of answers that name it. A list is published only when every assistant answered.

Selected rolling period: 288 answers (192 live, 96 from memory). Question set uk-2, run 16 November 2026.

  1. “What are the best historical romance novels ever written? I want something I can really get lost in.”
  2. “I've never read historical romance before, where should I start? Is there a good first book that isn't too heavy going?”
  3. “Can you recommend some of the best historical romance novels that have come out in the last year or so?”
  4. “Are there any underrated or lesser-known historical romance books that deserve more attention? I'm bored of the usual popular ones.”
  5. “I need a birthday present for my nan who loves Regency romances and cosy afternoon reading. What historical romance would you suggest?”
  6. “I've got a long flight to Australia coming up, what historical romance would keep me hooked for hours?”
  7. “Can you recommend some good enemies-to-lovers historical romances set in Regency England? Proper slow burn if possible.”
  8. “I absolutely loved Outlander and need something similar. What other historical romance books are like it?”
  9. “I've read everything by Georgette Heyer and loved it. Which historical romance authors should I try next?”
  10. “Which historical romance would be a good pick for our book club? We want something that will get everyone talking and disagreeing.”
  11. “What are the best historical romance novels written by British authors? Ideally ones with a proper British setting.”
  12. “Is there a historical romance series worth starting that I can binge over the next few months? Preferably one where each book can be read fairly well on its own.”

A list shows what the assistants said in the selected period through their APIs. It is not a ranking of quality or sales, and nobody pays to be on it. Repeated questions and shared models limit the independence of these answers. Read the method and limitations.